New York Pizza, located in Pleasanton, CA, offers an authentic taste of New York right in your neighborhood. With its inviting outdoor seating and a vibrant atmosphere, the restaurant quickly captivates diners with its warm and accommodating staff. Customers like Sara Smothers praise the light and crispy crust, noting the generous toppings on the BBQ Chicken Pizza as a standout. The unique choices—like the Gyro Pizza—showcase the restaurant's creativity, appealing to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters. The menu is rich with Italian favorites, including calzones and subs that balance comfort with flavor, while desserts like the Brownie Pizza and Tiramisu promise a sweet finish to any meal. Reviewers consistently highlight the hearty portions and quality ingredients, matched by the staff's genuine hospitality. The atmosphere, while maintaining a rustic charm, further enhances the New York vibe. Whether you're grabbing a slice on the fly or enjoying a family meal, New York Pizza seals the deal with an array of options that cater to all tastes. With its blend of flavors, welcoming ambiance, and attention to customer satisfaction, it’s easily positioned as a must-try destination for pizza lovers in Alameda County.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Does not have assistive hearing loop
No wheelchair-accessible car park
No wheelchair-accessible entrance
No wheelchair-accessible seating
No wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has outdoor seating
Offers kerbside pickup
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
On-site services available
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Serves halal food
Serves happy-hour food
Serves late-night food
Serves organic dishes
Has private dining room
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves vegetarian dishes
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has counter service
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with tourists
Popular with university students
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Accepts cheques
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Paid parking lot
Paid street parking
Plenty of parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Photos
Reviews For New York Pizza
Sara Smothers
May 3,2025
The Best Pizza I've had in a Long Time.The Crust was light & Crispy. I ordered a slice of the BBQ Chicken Pizza it was Delicious & heavy on the Toppings. They have Nice outdoor seating area too. I soaked up some sun, they also have Umbrellas. The Cashier Jamal Greeted me when I came in the Door. All the wait staff were very pleasant & accomadating. Thanks for a very pleasant experience my 1st time in. I will be back Sincerely Sara
PAY-IT-FORWARD PRODUCTIONS
Apr 10,2025
I read the reviews before I came. Some good some bad. So I decided to try it out. The look: ....Authentic. As in, a little rundown and could use a little added paint. It captures the bizarre nature of now york through bizarre choice of artwork. The service: ....authentic. As in, a little underwhelming yet hospitable. Exactly what you want and find in NYC. Dont look into this too much the staff is great. The food: unlike the negative reviews.... I found my pizza stacked with toppings, perfectly sauced, and the crispy thing crust is unlike anything I have found in New York. Nevertheless, it was next level. It was floppy like your find in the city but had a unique crispness that made it that much better. Overall for a snack or meal under 10 this is a great place to start your food journey in Almeda CA.
Vincent Tang
Mar 25,2025
New York Pizza Pleasanton has unique toppings. I saw the "Gyro Pizza" and I knew I had to try it. There were gryo toppings sprinkled across the pizza with a mix of pizza's traditional toppings like tomato sauce and cheese. There were plenty of indoors seats when I visited on a Saturday night (-11:00 PM). There is also an outdoor table if preferred. Their online menu seems to have more options than their in-person menu, so be sure to take a look (or make your own). Overall, a good spot for takeout with some unique toppings. I'd swing by again to mix and match even more.
Brenda
Mar 22,2025
I have been here a few times now with my kids because they love NY pizza. It's always simple and good.
Scott Sabado
Mar 15,2025
Never had a better experience , the owner is very kind and has been in the pizza business since the 80s ! Excellent food ! Best stop for lunch or dinner with the family!
Avish Shah
Mar 13,2025
Very thin crust pizza with amazing toppings at the heart of downtown Pleasanton. Party size pizza is sufficient for 4-6 people. Garlic Bread came like a little pizza which was really tasty. Tips: try some extra twists like their olive oil, Mayonnaise on top.
Kevin Kunze
Feb 25,2025
Authentic and delicious thin New York style pizza
S M
Feb 24,2025
First time visiting New York Pizza, and I have to say the staff is incredibly friendly! We ordered a slice of marinara and a veggie pizza for dinner, both of which were delicious. The seating is comfortable, making it a perfect spot to relax, hang out, and enjoy a bite. It was a pleasure chatting with Johnny—such a great guy! We’ll definitely be back. Love supporting local businesses that really take the time to care for their customers. The vibes are great. There is also plenty of parking nearby and downtown Pleasanton is very lively!
Reviews For New York Pizza